Let’s Put a Stop to All Violence

684738931_524cfbfb79_z

Violence Against Women Worldwide

In 2012, in the Republic of Guinea, a country located on the west coast of Africa, 92% of women and 66% of men that were surveyed agreed that a husband is justified in beating his wife for at least one of the following reasons:
  • she has burnt the food,
  • she has argued with him,
  • she has gone out without telling him,
  • she has neglected the children, or
  • she has refused to have sex with him.

These findings were quite alarming to me, especially because 2005 research by the World Health Organisation (WHO) indicated that a higher rate of violence occurs when it is accepted or justified. For example, in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where 64% of women are victims of violence by men, 76% of women also agree that a husband is justified in beating his wife for at least one of the five above reasons (ICF International, 2014).

To show just how much violence is a gendered issue worldwide, the country with the highest reported prevalence of women perpetrating violence against men was Gabon, with 22-23%, less than half the amount of women who report being victims of violence by men (46-47%). Of all the countries surveyed, only the Phillipines showed a higher prevalence of women perpetrators of violence against men (15%) than women victims of violence by men (12%; ICF International, 2014).

jakob-owens-168406.jpg

Although the rates of violence against women has already begun to drop in many countries around the world, much more work still needs to be done to change both violent behaviours and attitudes towards violence. Interestingly, a study by Jensen and Oster found that the introduction of cable TV in 21 rural areas of India between 2001 and 2003 led to both quickly improved attitudes (a 10% reduction rate in women who said that wife beatings were justified) and behaviours (girls between the ages of 6 and 10 were 8% more likely to go to school) in comparison to areas that didn’t have cable yet, where little to no progress was found during the same time. This gives me hope that increasing awareness really can make a difference.

Violence in Australia

When the Australian Government brought out the ‘Violence Against Women – Australia Says No’ campaign in 2004 and 2005 it helped bring attention to an issue that prior to this was not spoken about enough:

It tried to educate people that violence against women was not okay, that it was a crime, and that it was not deserved or in any way the woman’s fault.

It aimed to inform that hitting and not obtaining sexual consent are both considered violence.

It encouraged women and men to speak up about violence against women, for males and females to intervene if they knew that it was taking place, and for women to seek help by calling the national hotline or speaking to a friend or to the police if they were victims of violence.

It also encouraged men to stop committing violence and seek help if they were perpetrators, and to not adopt any violent behaviours towards women in the future if they had yet to do so.

Although the aims of the ‘Violence Against Women – Australia Says No’ campaign were important, the campaign was actually strongly criticised at the time, as it was developed hastily and simplistically, with very little consultation with stakeholders and specialised domestic violence services, and had a very narrow focus on what violence entailed. My first reaction to the campaign when I saw it was:

why just women?

Having been a victim of both domestic and physical violence myself, and being told by the police that there was nothing that could be done about it, I found it encouraging that a campaign was trying to raise awareness towards putting a stop to violence, but didn’t understand why it wasn’t just ‘Violence – Australia Says No’. I get that worldwide violence is more prevalent against women, but is this also the case in Australia?

I decided to investigate a little further…

In 2006, The Australian Bureau of Statistics (ABS) released their 2005 Personal Safety Survey. In this, approximately 350,000 women were estimated to experience physical violence in Australia each year, and 125,000 women were estimated to experience sexual violence (ABS, 2006). Now this number is far too high, and definitely needs to be brought down through better awareness and education, prevention, increased reporting rates and tougher punishment for perpetrators.

What seems to be less well known is that approximately 775,000 men are also estimated to experience physical violence in Australia each year, and 45,000 men were estimated to experience sexual violence (ABS, 2006).

A more recent finding from the results of the 2009-2010 ABS Crime Victimisation Survey support these estimates of more violence being perpetuated against males in Australia, with 56.6% of all assault victims being male, and 43.4% being female (ABS, 2011).

If the aim of the Australian Government is to stop violence in general, then I believe that gender needs to be taken out of the equation when looking at who the victims are. Men are just as likely, if not more, to be the victims of violence in Australia, and more needs to be done, such as the recent ‘One Punch Can Kill’ campaign to lower the impact that it has on our overall society.

opckfactsheet1

Does Gender Play a Role Towards Violence in Australia?

Gender becomes important when looking at who the majority of the perpetrators are. Males are much more likely to be the perpetrator of violence towards both males and females, especially in regards to sexual assaults, where approximately 93% of sex offences are committed by males (ABS, 2013-2014).

Obviously something needs to be done on a societal level to change the hyper-masculine ideal that we have for males. This includes males generally not being aware of what they are feeling, not expressing what they are feeling unless it is anger because it is considered “weak”, disrespecting or objectifying women, and glorifying violence, aggression and retribution. I have already gone into detail about the consequences of raising boys to not cry, or sending them messages such as “be a man”, “don’t be a mummy’s boy”, and “never back down” in a previous article.

Gender is also important if we focus just on sexual assaults or intimate partner violence, rather than violence in general.

In regards to intimate partner violence, an estimated 114,600 females are impacted in Australia each year, of which 43,800 is from their current partner and 70,800 is from their former partner/s. This is in comparison to the estimated 27,900 males that are victims of intimate partner violence each year, of which 8,400 is from their current partner, and 19,500 is from their former partner (ABS, 2006).

Sexual Assault

With sexual assaults, one study showed that by the age of 16, a similar rate of penetrative sexual abuse occurs towards females (7.9%) and males (7.5%). However, double the rate of non-penetrative sexual abuse occurred towards females (20.6% to 10.5%; Mamun et al., 2007). Another finding indicated over four times the prevalence rate of sexual abuse towards females (17%) than males (4%) since the age of 15 (ABS, 2012). Both children and females are therefore more at risk of sexual assaults than adult males, and something needs to be done about it. The 2015 video using the metaphor of a cup of tea is a relatively non-threatening way to clearly explain what sexual consent is and isn’t:

Itsonus.org is a campaign that is also working towards stopping sexual assault, by not only educating people but also raising awareness that one-in-five US women experiencing sexual assault by the time they finish college is way too high:

and that it is on us to do something about it:

A disheartening paper by Denise Lievore at the Australian Institute of Criminology highlights just how far we still have to go. Of all the sexual assaults that women report to survey interviewers in Australia :

  • only 14.9% will report the assault to the police,
  • only 30.52% of these reports will be recorded by the police,
  • only 32.81% of the assaults that are recorded will be proceeded against, and
  • only 61.3% of the proceedings will result in a conviction (ABS, 2008-2009)

What this means is that less than 1% of the women in Australia who are willing to report to someone that they are a victim of sexual assault actually sees their persecutor convicted of the crime.

The acquittal rate of sexual assault defendants (20%) is also nearly three-times higher than the acquittal rate of defendants of all other charges (7%; ABS, 2004). When it comes to sexual assault, the Australian legal system desparately needs to change too.

To summarise, in Australia:
  • Gender (and/or sex) is not a good predictor of who will be a victim of violence in general 
  • Men are more likely to be the perpetrator of all types of violence, especially sexual assault
  • Men are 2.2 times more likely to be the victim of physical violence
  • Women are 2.8 times more likely to be the victim of sexual assault
  • Women are 4.1 times more likely to be the victim of intimate partner violence

Now that we are clear on the facts about the different types of violence and their relationship with gender, we really need to focus on why it is still occurring at such high rates and what we can do about it.

Dr Damon Ashworth

Clinical Psychologist

2 thoughts on “Let’s Put a Stop to All Violence

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s